The Private Interview is 9 and 1/2 minute press-style interview with an optional 30-second closing statement where the candidate is expected to exhibit the qualities and attributes of a Miss America. Candidates will be judged on their overall first impression, personality, intelligence.

During the On-stage Interview Candidates respond to a question written by one of the judges. These questions are formulated based on topics discussed in the candidate's private interview. The contestant is judged on their sense of confidence, ability to hold a conversation, speak publicly, defend their views, and exhibit sincerity. In combination with the Social Impact Pitch, this portion is worth 15% of the candidate's score.

Immediately following the Onstage Interview, the candidate will deliver a 10 to 20 second Social Impact Pitch, which at her discretion can include a statement on her socail initiative’s importance, her work and plans with the initiative, or other educational information. In combination with the Onstage Interview, this is worth 15% of the candidate's score.

The talent competition is a 1 minute and 30 seconds representation of the candidates unique abilities and can be anything from singing, to dancing, to jump-roping, to presenting a monologue. This phase is judged on technical skill, execution, stage presence;  and the totality of all elements, including costume and props.

Evening wear is an opportunity for candidates to exhibit their sense of style and grace. Candidates are judged on their sense of confidence, personality, stage presence, and sincerity. In addition, their technique, including walk and posture is taken into consideration.